Entropies of multidimensional shifts of finite type may be impossible to compute

You need to know: Set {\mathbb Z}^d of vectors y=(y_1, \dots, y_d) with integer coordinates, countable and uncountable sets, computable real number.

Background: Let F \subset {\mathbb Z}^d be a finite set of |F| points in {\mathbb Z}^d, and let \Sigma be a finite set of |\Sigma| colours. Let L be any subset of |F|^{|\Sigma|} colourings of F. A translate of F by x \in {\mathbb Z}^d is the set \{x + y, \,|\, y \in F\}. A colouring of {\mathbb Z}^d in colours from \Sigma is called admissible for L if all translates of F are coloured according to a pattern belonging to L. The shift of finite type (SFT) defined by L is the set X of all admissible colourings of {\mathbb Z}^d.

For every positive integer n, let F_n be the set of points (y_1, \dots, y_d) \in {\mathbb Z}^d such that 1 \leq y_i \leq n for all i=1,2,\dots, d. For the SFT X, let f_X(n) be the number of different colourings of F_n which can appear in some colouring x \in X. The (topological) entropy of X is then defined as h(X) = \lim\limits_{n \to \infty} \frac{1}{n^d}\log_2 f_X(n).

The Theorem: On 7th March 2007, Michael Hochman and Tom Meyerovitch submitted to arxiv a paper in which they proved the existence of SFT X such that real number y=h(X) is not computable.

Short context: Because there are uncountably many real numbers and only countably many algorithms, there exist real numbers which are not computable. However, important real numbers naturally arising in mathematics and applications, such as \pi=3.14159... and e=2.71828..., are computable. The Theorem provides examples of real numbers which are not computable but quite meaningful, because SFTs are important objects of study in symbolic dynamics, and the entropy is their most studied invariant. The Theorem is a corollary of a more general result stating that a real number h\geq 0 is the entropy of some SFT if and only if it is right recursively enumerable, that is, there is a computable sequence of rational numbers converging to h from above.

Links: Free arxiv version of the original paper is here, journal version is here. See also Section 10.9 of this book for an accessible description of the Theorem.

Go to the list of all theorems

Leave a comment