The distortion of a knot in R^3 can be arbitrary large

You need to know: Euclidean space {\mathbb R}^3, Euclidean distance in {\mathbb R}^3, curve in {\mathbb R}^3, closed curves, self-intersecting and non-self-intersecting curves, arclength along the curve.

Background: A knot representative is a closed, non-self-intersecting curve \gamma in {\mathbb R}^3. Two knot representatives \gamma_1 and \gamma_2 are equivalent if \gamma_1 can be transformed smoothly, without intersecting itself, to coincide with \gamma_2. A knot K is the set of all knot representatives \gamma equivalent to a fixed knot representative \gamma_0. The distortion of knot representative \gamma is \delta(\gamma)=\sup\limits_{p,q \in \gamma}\frac{d_\gamma(p,g)}{d_{{\mathbb R}^3}(p,q)}, where d_\gamma denotes the arclength along \gamma and d_{{\mathbb R}^3} denotes the Euclidean distance in {\mathbb R}^3. The distortion of a knot K is \delta(K) = \inf\limits_{\gamma \in K} \delta(\gamma).

The Theorem: On 10th October 2010, John Pardon submitted to arxiv a paper in which he proved that for any C>0 there exists a knot K in {\mathbb R}^3 with \delta(K) > C.

Short context: The question whether every knot has a “nice” representative is well-studied for various definitions of “nice”, see here for an example. In 1983, Gromov asked whether every knot K in {\mathbb R}^3 have a representative \gamma with \delta(\gamma) < 100. The Theorem shows that this is not the case, with any constant in place of 100. In fact, Pardon presented explicit examples of families of knots with distortion going to infinity. For example, let \gamma_{p,q} be the curve in {\mathbb R}^3 defined by equations x=r\cos(p\phi), y=r\sin(p\phi), z=-\sin(q\phi), where r=\cos(q\phi)+2 and 0\leq \phi <2\pi. Set K_{p,q} of curves equivalent to \gamma_{p,q} is called the (p,q)-torus knot. Pardon proved that \delta(K_{p,q})\geq \frac{1}{160}\min(p,q). The Theorem follows.

Links: Free arxiv version of the original paper is here, journal version is here.

Go to the list of all theorems

Leave a comment